It’s chilly. It’s festive. It’s time to make some soup.
The Recipe
Sweet Red Pepper-Beet Soup, from Martha Stewart Living, August 2009 (also found on her website)
Scare Factor
Much like the Brussels sprout, and with no thanks to Dwight Schrute, beets don’t have the best reputation. They seem to be another food that not many people get involved with these days. The check-out guy at the grocery store this morning rang them up as radishes—no joke.
Like many others, I’ve enjoyed the occasional beet or two at a salad bar, but beyond that, they were pretty foreign to me. In addition, they’re not very pretty. They don’t exactly tempt their way into your shopping basket with their good looks.
Yikes.
Another veggie I would “meet” today, was the shallot. I had never purchased a shallot before, and was pleasantly surprised to see that they are basically tiny onions, but with slightly different coloring, and (to me) a little more pungent. Not too scary, but still a first.
The final scary step in the recipe—blending. I do have a blender, but I don’t like to use it. I had a bad experience once trying to “puree” a mixture of nuts, dates, basil, and olive oil for a different recipe. It ended with me beating a plastic baggie filled with said contents with a can of soup.
Here’s How it Really Went
When I’m cooking, I sometimes find it hard to really go through the recipe beforehand and prepare the ingredients so that they are ready when called for. But, I did today, and in doing so, realized that this wasn’t exactly the soup I thought I was getting myself into. It is to be served chilled. Not hot.
Well, okay. I guess those are the recipe rules, but… what would happen if I tried it hot? Nothing.
So I went forth. I chopped the shallots, and sliced the peppers into ½ inch pieces.
Then I moved onto the beastly beets. The recipe calls for them to be trimmed and peeled before being cut into ½ inch pieces. Trimmed? And how to you peel a beet?
I did some sleuthing online, and found a useful discussion board where people weighed in on their favorite methods for peeling beets. Unfortunately, 99% of these involved roasting them first. Well, my recipe didn’t call for roasting, but luckily I found one post from a guy who said he simply peeled them with a vegetable peeler, and said it wasn’t any harder than peeling a carrot.
A slightly more flattering shot
Well, it is a little harder, but not much. I never found out officially what trimming a beet means, so I took it to mean cutting off the top part connected to the leaves, and the creepy little tail/root that extends from the bottom.
One warning: these things are somewhat juicy. They don’t look like it from the outside, but they exude a deep fuchsia liquid that stains easily. Fortunately, I learned about this from the message board I had been reading earlier, and used a white washcloth (which is no longer white) to hold the beets as I peeled them, thus sparing my hands. This was a little tricky, though, and at one point, the whole damn beet fell into the garbage as I was trying to peel it.
Cutting the beets was easier than I thought it was going to be. I would just advise using a big knife. Beets are pretty solid.
Once everything was prepped, I went ahead and added the shallots, peppers, and beets into the pot, followed by the chicken broth and water. One thing that is absolutely stunning about this recipe is the colors, for which I credit the beets.
Following the directions, I partially covered the pot with its lid, and let it simmer for one hour. There’s nothing like a quiet, warm apartment with a pot of soup on the stove, and the timer quietly ticking away.
Ahh, peace.
Another warning: beets don’t smell great when they are being simmered for an hour. They don’t smell bad, per se, but they don't really make your mouth water, either. I had to open a window for a little ventilation.
After an hour had passed, I removed the soup from the heat, let it cool for about 10 minutes, and added the lemon juice and salt and pepper. Now for the part I dreaded almost as much as touching those ugly beets. Blending.
I ladled half of the soup into the blender, and then (from a different soup recipe I’d read), removed the little plastic cap from the center of the lid of the blender, and covered the hole with a washcloth. This is to let some of the heat escape.
Then, I made a classic mistake. I almost didn’t want to include it in this post, because it’s so cliché. But honest to God, it happened. I put the blender on it’s roost, plugged it in, and was immediately sent into my target heart rate zone as the blender started pureeing sans lid. Really. Who puts a blender away in the “puree” setting? Me.
Luckily, the mess was very, very minimal. I quickly wiped the red liquid off the counter and cabinet, put the lid on and blended away.
Once all of the soup was blended (I was able to do this in two batches), I poured it into a big bowl to place in the fridge to let chill. But, I still wanted to try it when it was hot. So I poured myself a small bowl, added some feta cheese (the recipe calls for goat cheese, but feta’s a little cheaper, so that’s what I used), and dove in.
The Verdict
Well, I hate to say it, but… I didn’t particularly enjoy it. I thought it was maybe because I was breaking the rules and eating the soup hot, but even after I tried it cold several hours later, I still didn’t really enjoy it.
I suspect this was due to my expectations. I was in the mood for a rich, thick, steamy soup for this chilly winter day, but instead ended up with a thin, chilled puree of a beautiful deep red color. Which, really, would be great for summer. You’d think I would have gotten the hint, considering I took this from the August issue of MSL.
Overall, I’d say to give this a try sometime in July or August. During the hot summer months, I think I would find this soup to be very refreshing, somewhat sweet, and slightly tart from the lemon and cheese.
But, as it is December and not July or August, looks like I’m headed to the Christkindlmarket for dinner tonight…